The Social Status Instinct: A Fundamental Driver of Human Nature

The human instinct for seeking social status is a multifaceted phenomenon that transcends cultures and eras. Rooted in our biological and psychological evolution, whether it involves hierarchy within reference groups, competition on social networks, or political, economic, social, sports, or cultural dynamics, status plays a crucial role in our behaviors and interactions.

Evolutionary Foundations of the Need for Status

The concept of social status is rooted in Charles Darwin's theory of natural selection. Individuals with high status within their group had better chances of survival and reproduction throughout evolution. Primates, for example, exhibit complex hierarchical behaviors that influence their access to food, mates, and other vital resources.

Since then, numerous studies in evolutionary biology and psychology have highlighted the central role of social status in the survival and reproduction of social species, including Homo sapiens. In an environment of resource scarcity, social status is a major asset that allows privileged access to food, sexual partners, protection, and care. Individuals better positioned in the social hierarchy thus have better chances of passing on their genes to the next generation.

Our hominid ancestors, like many other primates, developed complex behaviors aimed at acquiring, maintaining, and displaying their social status within the group. Dominance gestures, coalitions, submission rituals, etc., are all manifestations of this instinct deeply rooted in our biology.

Fundamental Social and Psychological Needs

Beyond its biological foundations, the quest for social status also responds to essential psychological needs in humans. Research in social psychology and cognitive sciences demonstrates that the need for belonging, recognition, and self-esteem are crucial for our mental well-being and personal balance.

Belonging to a group and recognition by peers provide a sense of security and self-worth that is indispensable. Similarly, occupying an enviable position within the social hierarchy brings a sense of competence and personal achievement. Conversely, social rejection or lack of status can have disastrous psychological consequences, such as depression, anxiety, or isolation.

Anthropology offers insight into how different cultures construct and express social status. Tribal societies, for example, often use rituals to establish and maintain hierarchy. Claude Lévi-Strauss's work highlighted how myths and rituals reinforce social status and stratification within communities.

Sociology examines how social status influences economic structures. Pierre Bourdieu introduced the concepts of economic, cultural, and social capital to explain how social classes maintain their position in society. For example, in labor markets, individuals from privileged backgrounds often have access to better opportunities thanks to their social network, not just their skills.

Ubiquitous Manifestations in Modern Societies

This relentless quest for social status deeply permeates our contemporary societies, even in areas seemingly distant from hierarchical competition. Research in sociology and social psychology shows that this instinct manifests in multiple spheres of our lives:

In the workplace, where individuals compete for prestigious positions, impressive titles, and high salaries, beyond their actual material needs.

In the ostentatious consumption of luxury goods or prestigious brands, allowing one to display their belonging to an elite.

In the fierce competition for access to education, diplomas, and the most coveted positions, a guarantee of high social status.

In the race for titles, awards, and honorary distinctions, true markers of success and peer recognition.

Thus, the quest for social status permeates most of our activities, including those that seem more "noble" or "selfless," such as scientific research or civic engagement. Our modern societies, plagued by fierce competition, offer multiple channels to satisfy this primordial instinct.

Excesses and Derivatives

However, this relentless pursuit of social status is not without negative externalities. It can lead to harmful, even pathological behaviors, at both individual and collective levels.

At the individual level, the frantic quest for status can lead to mental disorders such as narcissism, mythomania, or social anxiety. It can also push some to adopt dishonest, selfish, or cruel behaviors to achieve their prestige and recognition goals.

At the collective level, this dynamic of exacerbated competition weakens the social fabric, undermines cooperation and solidarity, and deepens inequalities. It fuels divisions, conflicts, and polarization within our societies.

Moreover, it severely distorts our collective priorities, diverting our efforts and resources towards the relentless pursuit of ephemeral social gratifications, to the detriment of crucial issues such as environmental sustainability, reducing inequalities, or improving public health.

Our Status Instinct Can Be Harnessed for the Common Good

It is entirely possible to establish incentives that promote a virtuous use of our social status instinct. This would necessarily involve education aimed at developing humility, altruism, and a sense of collective responsibility, in addition to self-assertion; a transformation of social values and priorities, giving less importance to ephemeral status markers and more consideration to real contributions to the common good.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

References

Aronson, Elliot . "The Social Animal" 

Bourdieu, Pierre. "La Distinction: critique sociale du jugement" 

Lévi-Strauss, Claude. "Anthropologie structurelle"