Twilight of the West? Echoes of History

Does History Repeat Itself?

Like a persistent melody, the cycle of emergence, peak, stagnation, and collapse of empires and civilizations seems to rhythm the narrative of Humanity. From the decline of Pharaonic Egypt to the end of the Ottoman Empire, passing through the fall of Rome or the collapse of the Maya Empire, examples abound, revealing essential lessons for our time, provided we wish to avoid repeating the mistakes of the past.

Historical Cycles: From Ibn Khaldoun to Toynbee

Ibn Khaldoun, in his Muqaddima (Prolegomena), introduces the concept of 'Asabiyya as the sense of collective belonging and social cohesion that allows a community to prosper. This sentiment, often associated with the masses, is also nurtured by the elites, who unite and direct the group. Ibn Khaldoun's innovative thesis is that empires emerge thanks to this strong social solidarity but eventually weaken precisely due to the decadence of their collective values.

Arnold Toynbee, a major British historian of the 20th century, studied the rise and fall of 21 civilizations. In his Study of History, he draws parallels, arguing that societies' responses to challenges determine their survival and posits that creativity in the face of adversity is a central driver of societal evolution.

These two thinkers, though separated by time and space, join their voices to express a well-supported observation: civilizations are not mere static entities but organisms in constant evolution, subject to cycles of prosperity and decline. They feed on the energy of their people, a vigorous 'asabiyya, and their ability to adapt and evolve in the face of challenges.

Illustrations

Take the Roman Empire, which brilliantly illustrates this cycle: its emergence was marked by the unification of the Mediterranean; its development relied on remarkable engineering and a flourishing culture. But decadence eventually took hold with internal power struggles, endemic corruption, and the loss of 'Asabiyya among the population. Ultimately, inertia, corruption, and the inability to respond to internal and external threats (notably barbarian invasions) led to Rome's fall, leaving behind centuries of disorder.

Similarly, the Ottoman Empire, after a period of rapid expansion, experienced a decline paralyzed by constant wars and internal revolts. This collapse, though different in context and form, also demonstrates the fragility of empires in the face of the loss of their social dynamism.

The Maya civilization, at its peak, was an impressive cultural and architectural power. However, environmental degradation, overpopulation, and internal wars destabilized it, with its elites failing to implement necessary adaptations.

The Role of Elites

It is primarily through their vision, innovation, and ability to unite that elites enable a society to unify, develop, and reach its golden age. Thus, the expansion of the Roman Empire or the British Empire was driven by visionary leaders capable of meeting the challenges of their time, as theorized by Arnold Toynbee in his work "A Study of History."

But when these same elites become divided, entrench themselves in their privileges, and become incapable of reinventing themselves, it marks the beginning of the end. Like the French aristocracy on the eve of the Revolution, the inertia and blindness of the ruling classes precipitate the collapse of their own system. This is the case today with Western societies, plagued by populism.

Parallels with the West

The West has experienced a meteoric rise over the past centuries. The Renaissance, the scientific revolution, and the rise of capitalism propelled Europe to the top of the world. But signs of "fatigue" are increasingly apparent. The unequal distribution of wealth, the rise of populism, the loss of trust in institutions, ecological crises, and the rise of nationalism are severely testing the social cohesion of the West.

The parallel is troubling. The Western 'asabiyya, once so powerful because cemented by universalist values, seems to be waning. The challenges facing Western countries, from climate change to social fracture, are unprecedented, questioning the resilience of their political and economic systems. The rise of populism in Europe and the United States is an alarming symptom of this degradation. These movements feed on frustration, fear, and exclusion, symptoms of a model that no longer works for the entire population.

Their rise indicates a deep malaise, an identity crisis similar to that experienced by many declining civilizations. This return to instincts, often characterized by the rejection of elites and traditional institutions, evokes the first signs of cracks in social cohesion, a prerequisite for eventual collapse.

Economic crises, growing inequalities, and a sense of insecurity fuel this populism. As observed by both Ibn Khaldoun and Toynbee, societies that cease to adapt to new realities and respond to the legitimate aspirations of their citizens trap themselves in a vicious circle, where stagnation inevitably precedes collapse.

Populist leaders, by cultivating division and rejecting reforms, multiply the risks of accelerating decline. Instead of addressing the major challenges of our time, they fuel fears and resentments, preventing any constructive reinvention. This mechanism was observed in the fall of the Ottoman Empire or the USSR.

Turning Point

History shows that civilizations that prosper sustainably are those that respond to their crises with creativity and by strengthening their social cohesion. The West is at a crossroads. Will it call upon the spirit of solidarity that could, as in the past, give birth to a renaissance of values and institutions, or will it persist in divisive rhetoric that will only accelerate its decline?

The cycles of emergence, development, stagnation, and collapse in history are not mere theoretical abstractions; they are warnings. Societies must learn not only from the mistakes of past civilizations but also from their ability to reinvent themselves.

The challenge of the 21st century lies in our ability to reweave the fragile thread of social cohesion, the foundation of a lasting civilization. 

Only a leadership capable of vision, courage, and unity can avert the fate of so many glorious past civilizations.

Will the West find within itself the vital forces capable of regenerating it?

---

References:

• Ibn Khaldoun - Muqaddima: Introduction to Universal History, which notably addresses the concept of 'Asabiyya and its implications on social cohesion.
• Arnold Toynbee - A Study of History, 12 volumes (1934-1961), where he analyzes the cycles of civilizations based on their ability to respond to new challenges.
• Peter Turchin - Secular Cycles (2009), which explores the socio-economic and political cycles in the history of empires, linking Toynbee's ideas to mathematical models.
• William H. McNeill - The Rise of the West: A History of the Human Community (1963), which examines the dynamics between civilizations and the social and political forces mobilized by elites.
• Joseph Tainter - The Collapse of Complex Societies (1988), which discusses the reasons behind the collapse of complex societies, emphasizing the importance of elite decisions in these processes.