Multifaceted Crisis of the West: No Choice but to Rise

In a profoundly transformed global context, the West, which has considered and presented itself since the Enlightenment as the ultimate beacon of Humanity, finds itself at a worrying crossroads, confronted with challenges and contestations that touch its intellectual, political, economic, moral, and demographic foundations. As emerging powers such as China, Russia, Iran, Turkey, and India increasingly challenge Western dominance, we are witnessing a slow but inexorable decline of this imperium that has shaped the modern world for several centuries.

Intellectual Decay: The Era of Post-Truth

The Western public discourse has undergone a dramatic transformation with the advent of "post-truth," a concept describing an era where emotions and personal beliefs take precedence over objective facts. This trend is fueled by declining trust in political, media, and academic institutions. The rise of far-right ideologies, as well as far-left movements, has also contributed to this intellectual erosion. Paradoxically, identity politics and wokism, claiming to defend minorities, have only created powerful divisions and fueled discord within Western societies. These struggles, which escape rationality, highlight a decline in intellectual standards, where the ability to dialogue and reason is undermined by simplistic and polarizing narratives.

Economic Stagnation and Rising Inequalities

The Western economy, once dynamic and a driver of global prosperity, is now experiencing a period of stagnation. Between 2000 and 2020, the West's share of global GDP has decreased in favor of emerging economies, notably China and India. Moreover, poverty, increasingly affecting young adults in developed countries, contrasts with the promises of shared prosperity, while deindustrialization erodes the productive fabric. This economic decline has given rise to a powerful sense of downgrading and resentment towards elites, significantly weakening social cohesion.

Political Crisis: The Fractures of the Democratic Landscape

The political landscape in the West is marked by a clear rise in fragmentation and instability. Liberal democratic systems, once seen as models, are now challenged by a spectacular rise of populist movements on both the right and left, exploiting popular discontent and endangering institutions. Violent protest movements, such as white supremacists, radical antifascists, and some environmental movements, exploit social tensions and create a climate of insecurity and chaos. Attacks on institutions and political representations reinforce this atmosphere of generalized mistrust, making dialogue difficult and hindering governmental effectiveness. This climate raises fears of a drift towards less democratic and more authoritarian forms of governance.

Demographic Decline: A Slow Agony

Demographic dynamics are another worrying indicator of decay. Many Western countries have fallen below the population replacement threshold, raising concerns about their future. As more and more young people face economic uncertainties, they often choose to delay or abandon traditional life projects, such as marriage and parenthood. These decisions, made in a context of growing precariousness and changing values, risk undermining the social fabric in the long term.

Moral Decay: The False Pretenses of Humanism

But it is undoubtedly on the moral level that the West's record is most damning and open to criticism. Western democracies are guilty of blatant contradictions between the humanist values they fervently proclaim and the realities of their policies, betraying the ideals of human rights and justice. The contradictions are striking and indecent. Criticisms regarding the double standard applied to international crises, such as those in Ukraine and Palestine, illustrate the failure of governments to embody these values when they choose – for geopolitical reasons – to support authoritarian regimes or ignore human rights violations. Moreover, the legacy of colonial crimes and the lack of progress on key issues such as climate change and biodiversity highlight a shocking gap between promises and reality, fueling a sense of injustice and irresponsibility. The twists and turns of Western foreign policy, often based on economic or strategic cynicism, reveal a lack of genuine commitment to the ethical principles proclaimed in speeches, supporting authoritarian regimes or sectarian movements on numerous occasions in the name of so-called "realism."

A (Depressing) Overview of Alternatives to Western Hegemony

In light of this picture of decay, the question arises whether the alternatives offered by emerging powers represent salvation.

• China: Totalitarianism and Ecological and Demographic Dystopia

China, with its authoritarian model and obsession with growth, presents itself as an alternative to the Western model. But behind the economic mirage lies a repressive system, where corruption is rampant, freedom of expression is stifled, and dystopian social control is omnipresent. While China has achieved economic feats, it has done so at the cost of large-scale ecological destruction, leaving a catastrophic legacy for future generations, and an accelerated aging of its working-age population. These systemic fragilities raise legitimate questions about the long-term viability of the Chinese model.

• Russia: Imperialist Nostalgia and Repression

Russia, for its part, finds itself trapped in a cycle of militaristic authoritarianism and nostalgia for a past empire. The regime of Vladimir Putin, while cultivating the image of a strong country, faces severe economic problems, with an extractive economy, rampant corruption, galloping inflation, and a large-scale brain drain posing serious threats to its future.

• Middle East and Asia: Models to Avoid

The cases of Turkey, Iran, and North Korea only drive the point home. Turkey, with its democratic regression under Erdogan, shows the symptoms of exacerbated nationalism barely masking serious economic difficulties. Iran, for its part, is locked in a contested oligarchic theocracy that ignores women's rights and violently represses its population. The Gulf countries, dependent on fossil fuels and whose economy is based on a modern form of precarious worker slavery, contribute to environmental destruction and fuel regional conflicts. Finally, North Korea embodies the pinnacle of delusional totalitarianism, where the cult of personality masks a devastating economic collapse.

• The Imperative of Renewal

This seemingly depressing assessment should not, however, lead us to abandon hope or reject the best of Western values (liberal democracy, fundamental freedoms, and human rights), which should rather be considered as a common civilizational heritage to defend and cherish. 

It should instead push us to recognize and question the glaring gaps between the proclaimed values and the actual practices, both in domestic politics and international relations. 

The West must wake up and transform. It must face its contradictions, correct its mistakes, and promote a fairer and more sustainable model. Promoting social justice, fighting inequalities, and protecting the environment are urgent challenges that must be addressed proactively. The current drift does not mean the end of history, but a pivotal moment. 

The future of the West, and the world, depends on its ability to learn from its mistakes, reconsider its priorities, and build a more equitable and sustainable model. 

The alternatives emerging to Western leadership are hardly better. China, with its totalitarian authoritarianism, endemic corruption, and Orwellian social credit system, cannot be the model of tomorrow. Russia, in its dictatorial drift and militarization, offers only a bleak future. Theocratic Iran, reactionary Turkey, delusional North Korea, or the Gulf's oil monarchies are no more promising. 

In conclusion, the choice facing the good wills of the West is simple: sink into pessimism, inertia, and nihilism, or engage with lucidity, courage, and humility in a process of profound and salutary transformation.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

References :

- "The Great Stagnation" from Tyler Cowen

- "The New World Order" from Henry Kissinger

- "China and the new world order" from François Godement

- "The End of the West" from Patrick Buchanan